2010年10月6日星期三

How far away from China the Nobel Prize?(诺贝尔奖距离中国还有多远?)

The annual list of published and award the Nobel Prize will lead to our discussion: How far away from China the Nobel Prize?
    
Since the inception of this award, has never honored a local people, it seems that this is an open cycle is not always around. For the Nobel Prize, the official Ye Hao civil matter whether it is the most talked about "how far the Chinese from the Nobel Prize?", From China's education system, research system, incentive system and other reasons, so we have been wandering in the Nobel prize outside the gate.
    
Nobel Prize is a dream of the Chinese people.
    
In fact, the Nobel Prize is not essential. Award winners are causal factors are not to see those projects are awarded the project a few years ago. So much to award-winning project, the specific causal factors is really the year award. Researchers nor to award the study, and certainly not while doing occasional "tribute project," won the prize was an accident.
    
Now look at the results of several is original, there are several significant projects.Identification of the so-called Project Leader are looking for a few judges, are acquaintances, even though these judges also have a great title, that the nerve to say nice. Then is to fill the gap, reach the international advanced level, have become stereotyped. Whether national or provincial level appraisal, are basically true. There was an old professor once said that he once participated in identification, said something "inappropriate", then, is considered abnormal, then a further appraisal of the basic class was not invited to participate. Then again, even reached the international advanced to fill the gaps but also pick up, just follow the path of others.
     
Nobel Prize for the originality requirement is very high. Original research based on current scientific and technological system can not support such a project, the failure rate is very high, a number of years without results, project progress reports how to write, how title to comment on how graduate students involved in the project are a big problem. So, if I go to choose research subjects to choose the easy knot sure, easy achievements subject, of course, the subject of this class are basically the subject of sealing, has been basically confirmed to validate a point of view, or the big issue the problem of small distal missing, no problem send several SCI, title, school and other issues resolved. However, like any major achievements, is a dream.
译者;谷歌翻译            作者;董慧民
本文来自新浪博客;http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_5f6db19a0100m7hv.html?tj=1
原文;

 每年一度的诺贝尔奖名单公布和颁奖都会引起大家的讨论:诺贝尔奖距离中国还有多远?
    自从这个奖项设立以来,还从来没有一个本土的国人获此殊荣,似乎这是一个永远绕不开的怪圈。针对诺奖,官方也好民间也罢,谈论最多的却是“中国距离诺贝尔奖有多远?”,从中国的教育体制、科研体制、激励体制等方面原因,使得我们一直徘徊在诺奖的大门之外。
    诺贝尔奖是中国人的一个梦想。
    其实,诺贝尔奖不是主要的。 获奖不获奖有偶然因素,看看获奖的那些项目都是若干年以前的项目。那么多可以获奖的项目,具体那一年获奖真的是偶然因素。科研工作者也不是为了获奖而研究的,当然更不是应景而做“献礼工程”,获奖了是意外。
    看一下现在的成果中有几个是原创性的,有几个是有重大意义的项目。所谓的鉴定都是项目主持人找几个评委,都是熟人,尽管这些评委也都有很大头衔,那好意思说不好听的。然后就是填补了国内空白,达到国际先进水平,都成了套话。无论是国家级还是省级鉴定,基本上都是如此。曾经有一位老教授曾经说,有一次他参加鉴定,说了一些“不合时宜”的话,被认为是异类,后来再有鉴定会之类的基本不邀请他参加了。话又说回来,即使达到了国际领先,填补国内空白也是拾人牙慧,追随人家的轨迹而已。
     诺贝尔奖对于原创性要求非常高。原创性研究依据现在的科技体制无法支持这种项目,失败率非常高,若干年没有成果,项目进展报告怎么写,职称怎么评,参加项目的研究生如何毕业都是大问题。因此,如果我去选择科研课题,肯定去选择容易结题的、易出成果的课题,当然这样的课题基本上都是填缝类的课题,继续验证某个已经基本确认的观点,或者大课题中遗漏的小末节问题,发几篇SCI没有问题,职称、毕业等问题迎刃而解。但是,想有大的成果,就是一个梦想。

没有评论:

发表评论